Hotel>Pennsylvania>Cumberland>Mountain Creek Tavern

Exterior & Views 1, Mountain Creek Tavern, Cumberland

Bedroom 2, Mountain Creek Tavern, Cumberland

Bathroom 3, Mountain Creek Tavern, Cumberland

Others 4, Mountain Creek Tavern, Cumberland

Others 5, Mountain Creek Tavern, Cumberland

See all photos

General Info

Reviews

Location

Accommodation Rules

About

Hotel

Mountain Creek Tavern

Cumberland, Pennsylvania

Reviews

See all

4.3/5

GoodFrom 20 reviews

5.0/523 May 2026

Cheryl • Trip with Friends

We only stayed one night but were pleased with the cleanliness and neatness of the room. Everything smelled fresh and was neatly arranged. Wi-Fi password is clearly noted and easy to connect with great service. You have to reach out to the personal to get your room code. They were quick and helpful in getting it sent to me so we could access the room since we would be in later. The only downside was how loud the a/c unit is in the room. It does a wonderful job of keeping the room comfortable but it is very loud when it kicked on and ran.

5.0/52 May 2026

Micah • Couple Trip

the room was immaculately clean and in a very quiet and pretty area! we were super impressed and will definitely stay again soon!

5.0/513 Sep 2025

Jesse

Walking distance to grandparent's old place & a wonderful opportunity to stay another night in Mt. Holly Springs.

5.0/53 Sep 2025

Ty • Family Trip

Quaint little room perfect fit for our stay.

5.0/53 Aug 2025

MICHAEL • Couple Trip

The manager went out of her way to make sure that we were able to access our room which was a little different since we got the best room in the house

5.0/510 Jul 2025

Sean

Very quaint and comfy.

5.0/522 Jun 2025

Kerryanne • Solo Trip

This property was quiet, safe and clean

5.0/59 Jun 2025

Joshua • Couple Trip

We had a wonderful stay! Our room was comfortable and clean and quiet. Perfect for our weekend trip :)

5.0/527 Apr 2025

Gwenn • Family Trip

I picked this hotel on a trip to visit Dickinson College with my teen and it was so much less expensive than the hotels in Carlisle proper. We were coming in late - after 8 p.m. - and I had to call ahead of time to get my room number and access to the key. The person on the phone was very pleasant and helpful. We found our way there on one of Pennsylvania's many winding little roads (that led right into Carlisle, about 10 minutes away). There were lovely snacks in the room that were devoured immediately by kid, and bottled water, a very thoughtful touch, especially since there isn't too much in the immediate area, although there is a dollar store nearby. The room was cute and clean, the TV was a Roku so we could log in and watch our own stuff, the wifi was free and worked perfectly, and the beds and bedding were soft, clean and comfortable. If you want a generic hotel room from a giant corporation, it's not for you. If you like supporting a local business and are looking for a comfy and cute place to spend the night near Carlisle, it's perfect.

5.0/524 Aug 2024

matthew • Trip with Friends

Old town feel humble

5.0/51 Jul 2024

Justin • Family Trip

Clean and comfortable and I would stay again. It was a good room on our road trip.

4.0/56 Feb 2026

Eric

Nice for what we needed

4.0/524 May 2025

Gabriella • Couple Trip

The outside and parking lot are a little run down but inside, the rooms are very nice, plenty of towels and toiletries. Mini fridge, microwave and a nice TV. Walkable area in “town”. About a half mile long Main Street with a few restaurants, an ice cream shop and some stores. Needed a place close to Shippensburg without spending hundreds of dollars during PIAA States track weekend and this was perfect.

4.0/51 May 2025

PAUL

The building is an old tavern and is old in appearance but the room was updated clean and very comfortable.

4.0/510 Nov 2024

Melissa • Solo Trip

It was a nice quiet out of the way place to stay.

4.0/524 Oct 2024

Mr. • Solo Trip

Good room for the price point.

3.0/518 Feb 2025

Verified traveler • Family Trip

The pictures are an inaccurate representation of the property where rooms are was dated building, doors and furniture. Shower didn’t get warmer than lukewarm. Smelt stale and musty. What I would expect at a cheap travel lodge or $50 room in this area.

3.0/510 Aug 2024

Joel • Couple Trip

While the room was clean and fresh smelling, there was damaged moulding, pealed paper from the Sheetrock on the ceiling and an old, strained regged in places carpet that should be replaced. The king bed had only one somewhat comfortable side. I never understood why hotels don't rotate their mattress to ensure even where. In their defense, the bathroom looked to be newly renovated. There were also a small coffee pot and a tray of snacks with water. Based on the bed I probably won't stay there again.

3.0/522 Jul 2024

Robert • Couple Trip

At first from the outside structure we were very concerned about staying here. It looked like an old hotel from the pass with a closed restaurant attached. Note on the door to call for assistance and we spoke with Misty who was very pleasant to speak with. She told us our room number and combo lockbox to get key for the room. Walking in it was nice to see room 10 was updated and clean. A few repairs needed on the walls and ceiling. There was a welcome basket in the room. We decided to stay but not knowing the community was concerned for the area. It turned out to be a safe area. Its basic but was clean and for one night passing through the area this room was find.

2.0/519 May 2025

Carl • Couple Trip

No onsite staff. But they were helpful and it worked out getting to our room. The carpet was positively disgusting. The room needed an update, but it was otherwise clean. Right on a busy thoroughfare and we heard trucks going by all hours. Property exterior was horrible and upkept.

Popular Facilities

Parking

BBQ Equipment

Accessible Facilities

Free Parking

Sports & Recreation

Picnic Area

Cycling/Mountain Biking

Hiking

Public Facilities

Accessible Parking

Parking (Free)

Other Facilities

Smoking Area

BBQ Facilities

Accesibility

Wheelchair Accessible

Info

No Elevators

In-room Facilities

Patio or terrace

Outdoor Furniture

Location

See maps

View on maps

31 S. Baltimore Ave., Mount Holly Springs, Pennsylvania, US

Nearby Destinations

All distances are measured in straight lines. The actual travel distance may be different.

Accommodation Rules

Check-in Procedure

Check-in3:00 PM-10:00 PM

Check-out11:00

Extra-person charges may apply and vary depending on property policy
Government-issued photo identification and a credit card, debit card, or cash deposit may be required at check-in for incidental charges
Special requests are subject to availability upon check-in and may incur additional charges; special requests cannot be guaranteed
This property accepts credit cards, debit cards, and cash

There is no front desk at this property. If you are planning to arrive after 8:00 PM please contact the property in advance using the information on the booking confirmation. Guests can access their accommodation through a private entrance. A virtual front desk provides assistance to guests. Information provided by the property may be translated using automated translation tools.

Want to check in early? Fill out the Special Requests form on the booking page.

About Mountain Creek Tavern

Mountain Creek Tavern Location
With a stay at Mountain Creek Tavern in Mount Holly Springs, you'll be on a river, within a 15-minute drive of Carlisle Fairgrounds and Mount Holly Preserve. This hotel is 0.3 mi (0.5 km) from Amelia Givin Library and 0.6 mi (1 km) from Trine Park.

Mountain Creek Tavern Facility and Service
Take in the views from a terrace and make use of amenities such as a picnic area and barbecue grills.

Mountain Creek Tavern Rooms
Make yourself at home in one of the 14 air-conditioned rooms featuring microwaves and flat-screen televisions. Complimentary wireless internet access keeps you connected, and digital programming is available for your entertainment. Private bathrooms with shower/tub combinations feature complimentary toiletries and hair dryers. Conveniences include coffee/tea makers and complimentary bottled water, and housekeeping is provided on request.

Room Type and Price

Wed, 26 Aug 2026 - Thu, 27 Aug 2026 (1 night)

1 Room, 1 Adult, 0 Children